Unraid vs TrueNAS: which should you run?
By Ryan Fournier · Reviewed by Claire Bergeron · Updated Choose Unraid if you want to mix drive sizes and grow one drive at a time, and you value a gentle learning curve — it costs a one-time licence (from roughly CA$65 to CA$170 depending on tier). Choose TrueNAS (free) if you want ZFS's checksums, snapshots and self-healing on matched drives, and you do not mind a steeper start. Both run well on the same N100 or Ryzen hardware.
Unraid vs TrueNAS, at a glance
| Unraid | TrueNAS | |
|---|---|---|
| Mixed drive sizes | no waste — full capacity | sizes a vdev to the smallest |
| Data integrity | ZFS pools optional | ZFS checksums, scrubs, snapshots |
| Grow one drive | anytime, single drive | add a whole vdev |
| Array speed | ~one drive (reads a file) | striped array speed |
| Cost | one-time licence ~CA$65–170 | free, open-source |
| Ease of use | friendly UI, easy Docker/VM | steeper, more technical |
| Best for | mismatched drives, gradual growth | matched drives, integrity, replication |
The verdict: which should you buy?
The core difference: how they use drives
TrueNAS runs ZFS, which stripes across matched drives and sizes a RAID-Z vdev to the smallest member — mixed sizes waste capacity. In return you get end-to-end checksums, scrubs that repair silent corruption, and instant snapshots. It is the choice when data integrity is the priority.
Unraid does not stripe: each data drive holds whole files on its own filesystem, protected by one or two parity drives. Mixed drive sizes cost nothing, and you add a single larger drive whenever you like. The trade is speed — reads come from one drive, not the array — and no ZFS-style checksumming on the array by default (though Unraid now offers ZFS pools too).
Cost, in Canadian dollars
TrueNAS is free and open-source. Unraid is a one-time purchase — tiers by drive count, roughly CA$65 to CA$170 in CAD at current pricing — with no subscription for the base licence. For a build you will grow drive by drive, many Canadians find the Unraid licence pays for itself in the drives it lets them reuse.
Which builder each suits
- Pick Unraid if you have a pile of mismatched drives, plan to grow gradually, want easy Docker/VM management, and prefer a friendly UI.
- Pick TrueNAS if you are buying matched drives, want ZFS integrity and snapshots, run replication to another ZFS box, and are comfortable with a more technical setup.
Both are excellent; there is no wrong answer, only a better fit. Size either with the RAID-Z or Unraid calculator.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases on Amazon.ca.
NAS drives on Amazon.ca by CA$/TB
Whichever model you choose, it needs CMR NAS drives rated for 24/7 use. These are the current best value per terabyte, live from Amazon.ca in Canadian dollars.
Read more
Frequently asked questions
Is Unraid or TrueNAS better for mixed drive sizes?
Unraid, decisively. It gives each data drive its own filesystem, so a stack of different-size drives all contribute their full capacity. TrueNAS/ZFS sizes to the smallest drive in a vdev, wasting the surplus.
Is TrueNAS free and Unraid paid?
Yes. TrueNAS is free and open-source. Unraid is a one-time licence (roughly CA$65–170 in CAD by tier), no subscription for the base licence.
Which is easier for a first NAS?
Unraid, generally — a friendlier UI and simpler drive management. TrueNAS rewards a bit more learning with ZFS's integrity features.
Ryan Fournier covers home-server hardware and efficiency at nasdrives.ca: the right power supply, the UPS, and what a NAS actually draws running around the clock, priced against Canadian hydro rates.
Reviewed by Claire Bergeron, Editor-in-chief