What drive should I buy to replace a failed drive in SHR?
Buy a CMR NAS drive at least as large as the failed drive: ideally the same size or larger. SHR uses the replacement immediately for the repair, and a larger drive future-proofs a later expansion. Avoid SMR drives, which can stall the rebuild. Brand does not need to match.
Last verified July 22, 2026 · 3 official sources checked Updated
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases on Amazon.ca.
For an SHR repair, the replacement rule is simple: a CMR NAS-rated drive, at least as large as the drive that failed. SHR is flexible about mixed sizes, so equal-or-larger always works for the repair itself.
Same size or bigger?
Same size is the cheapest fix and restores full protection. A larger drive costs a little more but sets up a future capacity gain: once enough drives in the pool are the bigger size, SHR releases the extra space. Because larger drives are usually cheaper per terabyte, sizing up on a replacement is often the better value.
Why CMR, not SMR
SMR (shingled) drives rewrite overlapping tracks, which collapses their sustained write speed during the heavy, continuous writes of a RAID rebuild. That can turn a rebuild from hours into days, or stall it. Every drive worth buying for a NAS repair is CMR: the table below is filtered to CMR only.
Which families qualify
Seagate IronWolf and IronWolf Pro, WD Red Plus and Red Pro, and Toshiba N300 are the NAS lines, all CMR. Enterprise drives (Seagate Exos, WD Ultrastar) are also CMR and often the lowest price per terabyte if you can accept the extra noise. Any of these makes a valid SHR replacement.
CMR NAS drives for an SHR repair, by CA$/TB
Live Amazon.ca prices in CAD, ranked by price per terabyte. The Recording column is verified against manufacturer documentation. Prices checked
| Model | Capacity | Recording | Price | CA$/raw TB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() Seagate Exos X22 22TB SATA 6Gb/s 7200RPM 3.5" Enterprise Hard Drive - ST22000NM001ENewbest price per TB CMR recording, SATA enterprise drive Amazon.ca · sold by ServerPartDeals · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$1,129Buy on Amazon | 22 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$1,129 | CA$51.33/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Seagate Exos X16 16TB 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s Internal Enterprise Hard DriveNew CMR recording, SATA enterprise drive Amazon.ca · sold by SS TRADE's · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$851Buy on Amazon | 16 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$851 | CA$53.17/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Seagate IronWolf 8TB NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD – 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s 7200 RPM 256MB Cache for RAID Network Attached Storage (ST8000VNZ04/ST8000VN004)New CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$465Buy on Amazon | 8 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$465 | CA$58.12/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Western Digital 20TB WD Red Pro NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD - 7200 RPM, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR, 512 MB Cache, 3.5" - WD202KFGXNew CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use Amazon.ca · sold by Amazon.ca · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$1,200Buy on Amazon | 20 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$1,200 | CA$60.00/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Seagate IronWolf Pro 28TB Enterprise NAS Internal HDD Hard Drive – CMR 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s 7200 RPM 512MB Cache for RAID Network Attached Storage, Rescue Services (ST28000NTZ00)New CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$1,725Buy on Amazon | 28 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$1,725 | CA$61.61/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Seagate IronWolf Pro 20TB Enterprise NAS Internal HDD Hard Drive – CMR 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s 7200 RPM 256MB Cache for RAID Network Attached Storage, Rescue Services (ST20000NTZ01/ST20000NT001)New CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$1,235Buy on Amazon | 20 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$1,235 | CA$61.75/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Seagate Exos M 28TB Enterprise Internal Hard Drive HDD - 3.5in 6GB/s SATA 7200RPM 2.5M MTBF (ST28000NM003K)New CMR recording, SATA enterprise drive Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$1,750Buy on Amazon | 28 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$1,750 | CA$62.50/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Seagate IRONWOLF ST8000VN004 Internal Hard Drive 3.5" 8000 GB Serial ATA IIINew CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use Amazon.ca · sold by Aero Malls · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$500Buy on Amazon | 8 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$500 | CA$62.50/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Toshiba N300 10TB NAS 3.5-Inch Internal Hard Drive - CMR SATA 6 Gb/s 7200 RPM 512 MB Cache - HDWG71AXZSTANew CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use Amazon.ca · sold by HYPER MEGA Electronics · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$630Buy on Amazon | 10 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$630 | CA$63.00/TB | Buy on Amazon |
![]() Seagate IronWolf Pro ST16000NE000 16 TB Hard Drive - 3.5" Internal - SATA (SATA/600), Mechanical Hard DiskNew CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use Amazon.ca · sold by Deals2You · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026CA$1,020Buy on Amazon | 16 TB | CMR ✓ | CA$1,020 | CA$63.75/TB | Buy on Amazon |
Related questions
- Can I replace a failed Synology drive with a bigger one?
- Can SMR drives be used in RAID?
- Does a replacement NAS drive have to be the same brand?
- How do I tell if my hard drive is SMR or CMR?
- Why is the Repair option not showing in Synology Storage Manager?
- Can I replace a drive in RAID 5 with a smaller one?
- Should I replace all NAS drives at once or one at a time?
- What is SHR and should I use it?
Sources
Every technical claim on this page is checked against manufacturer and standards documentation. Dates are when each source was last reviewed.
- Synology KB: Repair a Storage Pool (checked 2026-07-22)
- Western Digital: WD Red Plus / Red Pro product & recording-tech documentation (checked 2026-07-22)
- Seagate: IronWolf / SkyHawk product documentation (CMR) (checked 2026-07-22)









