Why did my RAID rebuild fail?

In short

Usually a second drive developed errors during the rebuild: the surviving drives are read end-to-end under load, which can expose a weak one, and on a single-parity array that crashes the pool. Other causes: an SMR or failing replacement drive, or the replacement being too small. Restore from backup and rebuild with healthy CMR drives.

Last verified July 22, 2026 · 2 official sources checked Updated

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases on Amazon.ca.

A failed rebuild is stressful because it often means data loss, but the causes are a short list.

The most common cause: a second drive faltered

A rebuild reads every surviving drive end to end to reconstruct the missing one. That full-surface read under sustained load is exactly when a marginal second drive throws errors or drops out. On a single-parity array (RAID 5 / SHR) that has no remaining redundancy during the rebuild, a second drive failing means the pool crashes and the rebuild fails. This is the classic RAID 5 failure story, and the reason large arrays prefer RAID 6 / SHR-2.

Other causes

What to do now

If the pool crashed, stop writing to it, do not reinitialize, and restore from backup (or consult professional recovery for critical data with no backup). Rebuild with healthy CMR drives, and adopt RAID 6 / SHR-2 plus a UPS to avoid a repeat. The table lists in-stock CMR drives.

Drives that solve this

Live Amazon.ca prices in CAD, ranked by price per terabyte. The Recording column is verified against manufacturer documentation. Prices checked

ModelCapacityRecordingPriceCA$/raw TB
Seagate Exos X22 22TB SATA 6Gb/s 7200RPM 3.5" Enterprise Hard Drive - ST22000NM001ENewbest price per TB
CMR recording, SATA enterprise drive
Amazon.ca · sold by ServerPartDeals · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
22 TBCMR ✓CA$1,129CA$51.33/TBBuy on Amazon
Seagate Exos X16 16TB 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s Internal Enterprise Hard DriveNew
CMR recording, SATA enterprise drive
Amazon.ca · sold by SS TRADE's · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
16 TBCMR ✓CA$851CA$53.17/TBBuy on Amazon
Seagate IronWolf 8TB NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD – 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s 7200 RPM 256MB Cache for RAID Network Attached Storage (ST8000VNZ04/ST8000VN004)New
CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use
Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
8 TBCMR ✓CA$465CA$58.12/TBBuy on Amazon
Western Digital 20TB WD Red Pro NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD - 7200 RPM, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR, 512 MB Cache, 3.5" - WD202KFGXNew
CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use
Amazon.ca · sold by Amazon.ca · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
20 TBCMR ✓CA$1,200CA$60.00/TBBuy on Amazon
Seagate IronWolf Pro 28TB Enterprise NAS Internal HDD Hard Drive – CMR 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s 7200 RPM 512MB Cache for RAID Network Attached Storage, Rescue Services (ST28000NTZ00)New
CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use
Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
28 TBCMR ✓CA$1,725CA$61.61/TBBuy on Amazon
Seagate IronWolf Pro 20TB Enterprise NAS Internal HDD Hard Drive – CMR 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s 7200 RPM 256MB Cache for RAID Network Attached Storage, Rescue Services (ST20000NTZ01/ST20000NT001)New
CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use
Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
20 TBCMR ✓CA$1,235CA$61.75/TBBuy on Amazon
Seagate Exos M 28TB Enterprise Internal Hard Drive HDD - 3.5in 6GB/s SATA 7200RPM 2.5M MTBF (ST28000NM003K)New
CMR recording, SATA enterprise drive
Amazon.ca · sold by THEKEYKEY · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
28 TBCMR ✓CA$1,750CA$62.50/TBBuy on Amazon
Seagate IRONWOLF ST8000VN004 Internal Hard Drive 3.5" 8000 GB Serial ATA IIINew
CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use
Amazon.ca · sold by Aero Malls · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
8 TBCMR ✓CA$500CA$62.50/TBBuy on Amazon
Toshiba N300 10TB NAS 3.5-Inch Internal Hard Drive - CMR SATA 6 Gb/s 7200 RPM 512 MB Cache - HDWG71AXZSTANew
CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use
Amazon.ca · sold by HYPER MEGA Electronics · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
10 TBCMR ✓CA$630CA$63.00/TBBuy on Amazon
Seagate IronWolf Pro ST16000NE000 16 TB Hard Drive - 3.5" Internal - SATA (SATA/600), Mechanical Hard DiskNew
CMR recording, SATA NAS drive rated for 24/7 use
Amazon.ca · sold by Deals2You · one bare internal drive; shipping and taxes not included · checked Nov 22, 2026
16 TBCMR ✓CA$1,020CA$63.75/TBBuy on Amazon

Related questions

Sources

Every technical claim on this page is checked against manufacturer and standards documentation. Dates are when each source was last reviewed.